Community services complaints and carers recognition in New South Wales

Who is a carer

The Carers Act (NSW) sets out who counts as a carer. Under s 5(1), a carer is someone who gives ongoing personal care, support and assistance to another person. That other person needs this help due to disability, a medical condition, mental illness, or frailty and old age.

Section 5(2) excludes some situations. You are not a carer if the care is paid work under a service contract, voluntary work for a charity or community group, or part of an education or training course.

Section 5(3) adds a further point. Being a spouse, de facto partner, parent, guardian, child, other relative, or living together does not by itself make someone a carer. What matters is whether ongoing care is actually provided.

What the Charter requires, and what it does not create

This is about the NSW Carers Charter, found in Schedule 1 (s 6).

Section 7 applies to a public sector agency. It must take all reasonable steps to make staff aware of the Charter, consult carers on policies affecting them, and consider the Charter when making HR policies that significantly affect a staff member’s caring role.

Section 8 applies to a human service agency. It must take all reasonable steps to ensure the Charter’s principles are reflected in its conduct, and must report on compliance in its annual report.

Section 9 limits remedies. It states that nothing in the Act creates a civil cause of action (a basis for suing), creates new legal rights, or allows review of a judicial or administrative act or omission. Section 9(2) adds that other laws requiring an agency to consider certain matters still apply; the Charter does not override them.

A student must not treat the Charter as a source of enforceable rights. It cannot be used to challenge a decision. Its force lies in agency conduct and reporting duties, not remedies.

Applying this in a problem question

This is a New South Wales scheme. When answering a complaint problem, first work out which of the five kinds of conduct under s 22(1) applies. This includes a failure to provide a service or a withdrawal of one.

Next, address standing (the right to bring a complaint). Use the genuine concern test in s 23(1), rather than searching for a fixed category of complainant. Section 23(2) simply gives examples of this test.

Then check whether s 23(3) applies. This covers unjustifiable interference, meaning interference that cannot be properly justified. If relevant, also work through the s 23(4) matters.

For a carer question, apply s 5(1) first. This requires ongoing care, plus one of four specified grounds of need. Then check the s 5(2) exclusions, which can remove someone from the definition.

Section 5(3) adds a further limit: a spouse, relative or co-resident is not automatically a carer. They only count if the actual element of care is present.

Finally, do not rely on the Charter as creating a right, or as a ground of review (a basis for challenging a decision). Section 9 rules out both uses.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.