Co-ownership and severance

Joint tenancy and tenancy in common

Joint tenants own the whole property together. No one holds a separate share. Each owns the whole, equally with the others.

This leads to the right of survivorship. When one joint tenant dies, their interest ends. The others keep holding the whole property. Nothing passes by will, since there was no separate share to leave.

Tenants in common hold separate shares instead. These shares can be equal or unequal. Each share can be sold, mortgaged, or left by will. There is no survivorship: on death, the share goes into the deceased’s estate.

This difference is not about splitting up the land itself. Under either form, no co-owner can keep the others off any part of it. Each co-owner can possess the whole property.

Which does the law presume?

Old common law rules favoured joint tenancy. This made sense then, since survivorship meant fewer owners over time, keeping title simple.

Most Australian jurisdictions have reversed this by statute. Now, a gift or transfer to two or more people is presumed to be a tenancy in common, unless the document shows a contrary intention. In New South Wales, this reversal comes from s 26 of the Conveyancing Act 1919.

Under Torrens title, the register shows which form of co-ownership applies. If it expressly states joint tenancy, that statement will be enforced.

Equity takes a different approach. Even where parties are joint tenants at law, equity will often treat them as tenants in common. This happens where they paid unequal shares of the purchase price, where they are partners, or where they jointly lent money on a mortgage.

Severance

Severance turns a joint tenancy into a tenancy in common. This ends survivorship going forward only. A will cannot sever a joint tenancy, because a will only takes effect at death, after survivorship has already happened.

Severance can happen several ways. One joint tenant can sell or transfer their share to someone else. This breaks the unity of title. The new owner becomes a tenant in common, but the remaining original owners stay joint tenants among themselves.

All joint tenants can also agree together to sever. Or their conduct, a “course of dealing,” can show they all treated the property as held in common. For example, negotiating on the basis of separate shares can count, even if the deal is never finished.

Some jurisdictions allow a joint tenant to sever unilaterally, through a declaration or a statutory transfer to themselves. Under Torrens title systems, this is usually done by registering a transfer, following rules set by statute.

Severance can also happen automatically by operation of law. Examples include bankruptcy, and, in some jurisdictions, one joint tenant unlawfully killing another.

Whether conduct counts as a “course of dealing” is the most litigated issue. Just privately intending to sever is not enough if it is never communicated. Generally, even a firm offer to sell that is rejected is not enough either.

Rights and obligations between co-owners

Each co-owner can possess the whole property. If only one co-owner occupies it, they usually don’t owe the others occupation rent (payment for using the space).

This changes in two situations. First, if they ousted (forcibly excluded) the other co-owners. Second, if they claim back money for improvements or expenses, the others can set off occupation rent against that claim.

If a co-owner collects rent from a third party, they must account to the other co-owners for their share.

A co-owner who pays more than their share of mortgage instalments, rates or necessary repairs can claim contribution from the others. This claim is usually settled on final adjustment, not as an ongoing debt.

Terminating co-ownership

Co-ownership can end three ways: the owners agree, one owner buys out the others, or a court orders it.

A co-owner can apply to court for sale or partition. Partition means physically dividing the land between the owners, instead of selling it.

Courts usually order sale rather than partition. Partition only makes sense where the land can actually be split sensibly.

Courts rarely refuse this remedy. A co-owner is normally allowed to cash in their share, though the court may consider any agreement saying otherwise, or hardship to the other owners.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the form of co-ownership. Check the instrument, the register, and any statutory presumption.

If someone claims a joint tenancy, test it against the four unities (the four conditions needed for a joint tenancy to exist).

Equity may still treat the parties as tenants in common, even if the legal title says joint tenants. Unequal contributions and partnership are the usual reasons for this.

Next, work through any severance (an act that ends a joint tenancy) in date order. Be exact about when each event happened, especially relative to a death.

Keep questions about occupation, rent and contribution separate. These are accounting issues, not questions about who holds title.

Deal with sale or partition last. Identify the statutory power involved and the adjustments likely to follow.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.