Settlement and alternative dispute resolution

Why settlement and ADR matter

Going to trial is costly and slow. Even a strong case can lose, or win a result not worth the cost. Settlement lets parties control the outcome and shape solutions a court can’t order, like an apology or an ongoing business relationship.

Courts also want parties to settle. This frees up judges to focus on disputes that truly need a decision.

Because of this, Australian courts often encourage, and sometimes require, parties to try alternative dispute resolution (ADR) before or during a case. The most common form is mediation: an independent person helps the parties negotiate, but cannot force a result.

Some courts also use other methods, like case appraisal or conciliation. These are more common in specialist courts.

Mediation and other ADR

Mediation helps parties talk and consider options. The mediator does not decide the dispute. Any outcome must be agreed by the parties.

This differs from arbitration. There, an independent arbitrator does decide the dispute, usually bindingly. This happens under a separate process the parties agreed to, by contract or referral.

Mediation only works if parties speak honestly about their case’s strengths and weaknesses. This openness needs protection, so without-prejudice rules matter here.

Without-prejudice privilege

Without-prejudice privilege protects genuine settlement talks. These communications generally can’t be used in court to prove a party admitted something, or conceded their case was weak.

The reasoning behind this is practical: if offers to settle could be used against you, people would stop making them. That would discourage early settlement.

Both parties to the negotiation hold this privilege. It generally needs both to waive it, though it can fall away in certain situations — for example, if a party later tries to prove a settlement was actually reached.

In the uniform evidence jurisdictions, these exceptions are set out by statute. One is important here: the privilege doesn’t apply where the communication is relevant to deciding who pays costs[^cite:evidence-act-1995-cth-s-131].

Offers of compromise and costs consequences

Quick Read: Offers of compromise and costs

There is another tool alongside without-prejudice negotiation: a formal offer of compromise, or a Calderbank offer (from Calderbank v Calderbank). These offers stay open for acceptance but are reserved on costs.

They are usually marked “without prejudice save as to costs.” This means the judge cannot see them before judgment, but can see them afterward when deciding costs.

The consequence matters. If a party rejects a reasonable offer, then does worse at trial than the offer would have given them, they may face an adverse costs order. This often means paying the other side’s costs from when the offer expired, sometimes on a harsher costs basis.

This creates a real incentive to take settlement offers seriously. Winning at trial can still leave you financially worse off than if you had accepted the offer.

Two Australian cases are more important than the original English one. In Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority, the Victorian Court of Appeal rejected the idea that refusing an offer automatically creates a presumption of indemnity costs. Instead, the court held there should be no fixed preconceptions about when a special costs order should follow. What must be shown is that the rejection was unreasonable.

In Agosti & Agosti, Wilson J clarified what Calderbank actually decided: the original case simply awarded the wife her costs. The later case Cutts v Head treated the costs principle as dictum (a comment not essential to the decision), not as a binding holding. The lesson: cite the modern Australian authority for this principle, not the English case, which never actually established it as a rule.

Applying this in a problem question

When answering a problem question, start by asking if a communication was a genuine attempt to settle. Without-prejudice privilege only protects genuine settlement attempts, not everything said during a dispute.

Next, separate mediation from arbitration. Mediation is facilitative and non-binding unless the parties reach a settlement. Arbitration gives a binding decision made by a third party.

Then check if a formal offer of compromise was made. Note its terms, and whether it was reserved on the question of costs.

Finally, compare the trial result to any rejected offer. This comparison helps you assess likely costs consequences.

Remember settlement is not a lesser or failed outcome. For most disputes, it is simply the normal way a proceeding ends.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.