Interrogatories and admissions: narrowing the issues before trial

Choose between a question and a proposed admission

A question asks for information. For example, “Which employee authorised this delivery?” asks the other side to tell you something.

An admission asks the other side to accept a specific fact. For example, “Admit that the delivery arrived on 4 May” is a defined factual proposition, not an argument. Do not ask someone to admit a whole argument without breaking it into facts. This hides what is really agreed or disputed.

Documents raise a separate issue. Admitting a document is authentic does not mean admitting everything written in it is true. It also does not mean admitting the document proves liability.

South Australia’s rules let notices also address relevance or admissibility, not just authenticity. So even what a document notice can ask differs between states. Always state precisely what your notice is asking.

Interrogatories: permission is not uniform

The Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr21.01–21.02, require an order with an affidavit annexing the questions. The application waits fourteen days after pleadings close. If discovery was ordered, parties must have already served their lists. The Court sets the time for answering.[^cite:cth-procedure]

Each State and Territory sets its own entry rule for interrogatories, so practice is not uniform.

In NSW, r22.1 requires an order only where necessary. Some claims, like death or bodily-injury claims, also need special reasons. In Victoria, r30.02 allows service without leave once pleadings close, but further interrogatories need leave.

In Queensland, rr229–230 require leave, and questions are usually capped at thirty. In WA, O27 r1 requires leave to serve questions about matters in dispute. In SA, r117.5 requires prior leave, usually limited to one set, with a cutoff tied to discovery or trial listing.

In Tasmania, rr405 and 408A allow delivery before the matter is ready or set down. But a recipient can, within fourteen days, flag questions that need leave before they must be answered. In the ACT, r630 requires an order supported by an affidavit attaching the proposed questions. In the NT, r30.02 requires leave to serve questions relating to a matter between the parties.

These differences matter for strategy. Queensland’s r230 only grants leave where no other simple, inexpensive way to prove the matter is likely available. Tasmania’s r408A exception means flagged questions need leave based on necessity or special reasons, so Tasmania cannot simply be grouped with either unrestricted service or universal advance leave.[^cite:qld-procedure][^cite:tas-procedure]

Notices to admit: the consequence of silence

A notice to admit asks the other side to accept facts, or that a document is genuine. Ignoring it can carry consequences.

In the Federal Court, rr22.01–22.04 let a party serve such a notice. The other side has fourteen days to dispute it properly, or the fact or document is deemed admitted. The Court may excuse non-compliance under r1.34, and withdrawing an admission needs leave. An admission can support judgment, but only for relief it actually proves.

NSW rr17.3–17.4 work similarly: fourteen days to dispute, with admissions deemed only in that case and only for the requesting party. Leave is needed to withdraw. Queensland r189 (for claims under r186) and ACT r491 use the same fourteen-day deeming approach.

Victoria and the Northern Territory instead set their own notice period, which must be at least fourteen days. That minimum is not a fixed universal deadline.

Tasmania differs more sharply. Under r399, failing to dispute a document’s authenticity within fourteen days can deem it authentic, unless the court orders otherwise. Under r401, failing to admit a fact in time usually just means paying the costs of proving it, not automatic admission -- subject to reasonableness or another order. Silence does not admit facts across Australia.

Western Australia’s O30 separates these further. Rule 2 allows a notice to admit facts, with withdrawal or amendment on just terms, but sets no automatic fourteen-day deeming. Rule 5 deems a document authentic if undisputed within seven days after the time for inspection, unless otherwise ordered. Rule 4 separately covers documents produced on discovery. Each mechanism has its own trigger and timing.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →