Discovery rules and the duty of disclosure

Three ways the obligation arises

Three ways the disclosure duty can arise.

In Queensland, r 211(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules creates the duty automatically. A party must disclose documents directly relevant to the pleadings, or to the issues if there are none. No notice or order is needed, and r 214(2)(e) sets the usual deadline at 28 days after pleadings close.

The Northern Territory is also automatic. Once pleadings close, r 29.02(1) of the Supreme Court Rules says discovery occurs. But r 29.02(2) lets parties agree to limit or dispense with it.

Victoria, Western Australia, Tasmania and the ACT require a notice. In Victoria, after pleadings close, a party may serve a notice in Form 29A under r 29.02(1) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2025. This only applies to proceedings begun by writ, or ordered under r 4.07(1) (r 29.01(1)).

In WA, Order 26 r 1 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 lets any party give written notice requiring discovery, but the court’s leave is needed once the matter is listed for trial.

In Tasmania, a party served with notice after pleadings close has 14 days to produce discoverable, non-privileged documents, and must serve a list if the notice asks (rr 383(1), (2)(a)).

In the ACT, r 607 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 allows a notice to disclose, but not before pleadings close or after the hearing is listed, unless the court gives leave. The recipient then has 28 days to file a list, a verifying affidavit, and, if represented, the solicitor’s certificate of advice.

The Federal Court and NSW require a court order first. Under r 20.12(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011, a party must not give discovery without one. Giving discovery without an order means no costs or disbursements are recoverable for it (r 20.12(2)).

Three scope tests, and the reasonable search

Australian discovery rules use three different scope tests. They are not interchangeable. They run from broadest to narrowest.

The first test, used in the ACT and WA, is “relating to a matter in question”. ACT r 605(1) catches documents that relate, directly or indirectly, to a matter in issue, or are mentioned in a pleading or notice. Under r 605(5), a matter stays “in issue” until it is admitted, withdrawn, struck out or otherwise disposed of. WA’s O 26 r 1(1) uses similar wide wording: “relating to any matter in question”.

The NT uses related wording but narrows it. Rule 29.02(1) covers documents “relating to a question raised by the pleadings”. But r 29.02(3) removes the wider “train of enquiry” extension: a party need not discover a document that is relevant only because it might lead to further material. This exception does not apply where the pleading contains allegations under r 13.10(3), and the court can still order otherwise.

NSW uses a narrower second test: “relevant to a fact in issue”. Rule 21.2(4) bars a discovery order unless the document meets this test. Rule 21.1(2) defines it: the document could rationally affect the probability of a fact existing, not merely by affecting a witness’s credibility, whether or not it would be admissible in evidence. Rule 21.2(2) also stops parties describing a class of documents more broadly than the court thinks justified.

The third approach, used by the Commonwealth, Tasmania and Victoria, defines discovery through four set categories. Commonwealth r 20.14(1) requires “standard discovery” of documents directly relevant to issues raised by the pleadings or affidavits, that the party knows of after a reasonable search, and that are or were in its control. Rule 20.14(2) narrows this further: the document must be one the party will rely on, or one that hurts its own case, helps another party’s case, or hurts another party’s case. Tasmania’s r 382(1) and (2) state the same four-limb test.

Victoria’s r 29.01.1(3) sets out the same four categories, but makes them exhaustive. Unless the court orders otherwise, discovery is limited to those four categories, and this limit applies “despite any other rule of law to the contrary”.

The continuing obligation

All eight jurisdictions treat disclosure as a continuing duty, but each uses its own rule and wording.

In the Federal Court, r 20.20 covers any document the order would have required, except a privileged document created after the proceeding started. New South Wales (r 21.6) requires immediate notice and access if a document was missed or a privilege claim was wrong or has lapsed. Victoria (r 29.15) and the Northern Territory (r 29.16) both cover documents found after discovery was made.

Queensland (rr 211(2), 214(2)(d)) imposes the duty itself, with a new document listed within 7 days. Western Australia (O 26 r 2) requires discovery immediately, right up to the end of trial, subject to a final deadline described below. Tasmania (r 382(1)) keeps the duty going unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise. The Australian Capital Territory (r 611) requires a wrongly omitted or later-received document within 7 days, or immediately if the hearing is near.

Two jurisdictions need more detail. In Queensland, the duty of disclosure continues “until the proceeding is decided” (r 211(2)). Under r 211(3), an allegation stays “in issue” until it is admitted, withdrawn, struck out, or otherwise resolved.

In Western Australia, the duty runs until the trial ends. A newly found document must be disclosed immediately (O 26 r 2(4)). This does not apply to a document created after discovery was given that is privileged, or that passed between the parties or their lawyers.

Even those excepted documents are caught by a final deadline: at least 21 days before trial, a party must disclose any document not yet discovered (r 2(5)).

Narrowing discovery, and the price of not disclosing

Courts can limit how much discovery a party must give. Each jurisdiction has its own test for this.

Under Commonwealth r 20.11, a party cannot even apply for a discovery order unless it will help resolve the case “as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible”. This is a strict threshold before any application can be made.

In Victoria, r 29.05 lets the Court limit discovery, or refuse it, “to prevent unnecessary discovery”. It can restrict discovery to specified documents, classes, or questions.

Western Australia’s O 26 r 7(3) similarly allows the Court to confine discovery to specified documents, or to those directly relevant to particular issues. It may also delay or refuse discovery altogether at that stage.

Under O 26 r 11, an order for production of documents can only be made if the Court thinks it is “necessary” for a fair hearing or to save costs. This limits when parties can be forced to produce documents.

Tasmania’s r 389 gives the Court power to dismiss, adjourn, or refuse a discovery application if discovery is not necessary. This applies when discovery is not needed for a fair resolution or cost savings.

Queensland r 224 lets the court excuse a party from disclosure, wholly or partly. The court weighs the cost and inconvenience of disclosure against the issue’s importance, the amount involved, and its likely effect on the case outcome.

Failing to disclose also has consequences, and these differ by jurisdiction. In Queensland, r 225(1) says a party who fails to disclose a document cannot use it as evidence at trial without the court’s leave. That party may also face contempt proceedings, and may have to pay costs.

Under r 225(2), the other party can respond by asking for a stay, dismissal of the case, judgment against the defaulting party, or an order requiring disclosure in a specific way and timeframe.

In the Australian Capital Territory, r 674 applies where a party fails to disclose without a reasonable excuse. That party cannot use the undisclosed document as evidence against the other side without leave, and must pay any costs the failure caused. The rule makes clear the court’s other powers still apply.

Applying this in a problem question

First, identify the court. Then check whether disclosure applies automatically, needs a notice, or needs a court order first. Don’t use one court’s rule number in a different jurisdiction.

Next, state the scope test in that court’s own wording. This could be the four categories, “relevant to a fact in issue”, or the broader “relating to a matter in question”. Apply it to the disputed document.

Check if the rules treat a reasonable search as part of discovery. If they do, work through the listed factors.

Keep privilege separate from the rule’s own excluded categories. Deal with both issues.

Work out what the continuing obligation (the duty to keep disclosing) requires after the first list is served. Identify the time allowed for documents found later.

If a document was not disclosed, name the consequence the rules impose. Say whether it affects tender of the document, costs, contempt, or the proceeding itself.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.