Charitable trusts
Why purpose trusts are usually void
A normal private trust needs beneficiaries. Someone must be able to go to court and force the trustee to act. A trust for a vague purpose usually fails, because no one has standing to enforce it. This is called the beneficiary principle.
Charitable trusts are different. The Attorney-General enforces them on the public’s behalf, so having no beneficiaries is not a problem.
Other rules relax too. The trust does not need named recipients, as long as there is a general charitable intention; the court can fill in the details. The rule against perpetuities does not limit how long a charitable trust lasts, and property can move between charities without breaching it. Charities also get tax concessions, which is why charity status disputes often arise in tax cases.
Public benefit
A charitable purpose must benefit the public, or at least a big enough part of it. This test has two elements.
First, benefit: the purpose must actually be beneficial. This is judged objectively, not by what the settlor (the person creating the trust) believed.
Second, public: the group helped must not be too small to count, and must not be chosen by a personal connection, like working for one company or being descended from one person. Poverty cases are treated more leniently, so trusts to help “poor relations” have been allowed.
For three of the four charitable heads, benefit is simply assumed. For the fourth head, benefit must be proven. A statutory scheme has qualified this assumption for Commonwealth purposes.
Political purposes
Courts used to say a trust aiming to change the law could not be charitable. The reasoning was that courts cannot judge whether a law change benefits the public.
Aid/Watch Incorporated v Commissioner of Taxation (2010) 241 CLR 539 rejected this general rule for Australia. It held that public debate about government activity can itself be beneficial, because our constitutional system assumes this.
This does not mean every advocacy group is charitable. The group’s purpose must still fit a recognised charitable category and meet the public benefit test. A group set up to support a specific political party or candidate is still not charitable.
Exclusively charitable
A charitable trust’s purposes must be exclusively charitable. This means every purpose must count as charitable, not just some of them.
A trust for “charitable or benevolent purposes” fails. The word “or” lets the trust apply to non-charitable ends too, so it is not exclusive.
Some jurisdictions have statutes that save such trusts. They do this by cutting out the non-charitable purpose, or limiting the trust to charitable use only. Check the local provision before deciding the trust fails.
A trust can still include non-charitable activities if they are merely ancillary. This is allowed when the activity is just a means of achieving the charitable purpose, not a separate end in itself.
Cy-près
If a charitable purpose fails, the property does not automatically go back to the settlor. Courts can instead use cy-près, applying the property to a similar purpose.
If the purpose fails from the start (initial failure), cy-près only applies if the settlor had a general charitable intention. This means the settlor meant to support charity broadly, not just one specific body. For a gift to a named charity that never existed or has ended, courts ask whether the settlor’s main aim was charity generally, or that charity alone.
If the purpose fails after the trust has already started (subsequent failure), the property is already committed to charity. Cy-près then applies automatically, without needing to show general charitable intention.
Legislation has also expanded when cy-près can apply. It now covers purposes that no longer give a suitable and effective use of the property, or that have already been adequately met another way.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what the question is really asking. The rules for trust validity, revenue treatment, and regulatory registration are different, so check which one applies.
Next, fit the purpose into a recognised head of charity. Name the head you are using.
Then test public benefit on its own. Look at both the benefit element and the public element, remembering that for some purposes benefit is presumed.
Check the purposes are exclusively charitable. If they are not, see whether a saving provision can help.
Finally, if the purpose has failed, decide whether the failure is initial or subsequent. That decision comes before asking whether general charitable intention must be proved.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.