Chapter III and state courts

The Commonwealth position: Boilermakers

Boilermakers’ Case (1956) set a strict rule at the federal level, called the separation of judicial power. Only a Chapter III court can hold the judicial power of the Commonwealth. This means the High Court, a federal court Parliament creates, or a state court given federal jurisdiction.

A federal court cannot be given extra functions unrelated to judicial power. This rule applies to federal courts under Chapter III, not to state courts. The case itself involved the federal Arbitration Court.

The reason for the rule is to protect judicial independence. Section 72 protects judges’ tenure and pay to secure this independence. But this only limits Commonwealth power. A State may still give judicial power to a body that is not a state court, outside matters listed in ss 75 and 76.

There are exceptions. A judge can take on non-judicial tasks personally, not as part of the court. This is called the persona designata exception. Courts can also exercise discretionary powers if these are incidental to their judicial role.

Persona designata and incompatibility

Even the persona designata exception has a limit. A function given to a judge personally is invalid if it is incompatible with judicial functions, or with the integrity of the judge’s court.

Incompatibility asks whether the function stops the judge doing judicial work properly, or harms the judiciary’s institutional role. In Grollo v Palmer (1995) 184 CLR 348, the majority described three situations. The function may take up so much time that real judicial work becomes impracticable. It may compromise the judge’s integrity in judicial work. Or it may damage public confidence in the judiciary’s integrity, even without affecting the judge personally.

Missing the usual judicial process does not, by itself, prove incompatibility. In Grollo, the Court accepted that issuing an interception warrant lacks ordinary judicial features: it is ex parte, secret, has no return date and needs no reasons.

Despite this, the Court held that giving Federal Court judges this warrant power as personae designatae was valid. The incompatibility condition was not triggered.

Finally, a judge’s consent to take on the function does not fix an incompatibility problem if one exists.

The States: no separation of powers requirement

State constitutions don’t require separation of judicial power. This means state parliaments have more freedom than the Commonwealth does.

A state parliament can give non-judicial functions to its courts. It can also give judicial power to a body that isn’t a state court. The exception is matters listed in ss 75 and 76 of the Constitution.

States are free to organise their courts as they choose (Wainohu v New South Wales, French CJ and Kiefel J). But they cannot abolish the state’s Supreme Court.

This freedom has limits. Those limits come from Chapter III itself.

Kirk and the entrenched supervisory jurisdiction

Kirk v Industrial Court (NSW) says every state Supreme Court has a key feature. It can supervise lower courts and tribunals, keeping them within their legal powers. It does this by granting relief for jurisdictional error (a mistake that goes beyond a body’s legal authority).

Because this supervisory power defines a state Supreme Court, a state parliament cannot take it away. If a law (a privative clause) tries to block court review, courts will either limit its effect or treat it as invalid. The reasoning was structural: allowing it would create “islands of power immune from supervision and restraint” — bodies answerable to no one.

This has two effects. First, jurisdictional error now matters constitutionally at the state level, similar to its role under s 75(v) at the federal level.

Second, the line between jurisdictional and non-jurisdictional error still matters. Many thought this distinction was fading, but it remains important. Only jurisdictional error is protected from being shut out by a privative clause.

Federal jurisdiction in state courts

Section 77(iii) lets the Commonwealth Parliament give state courts federal jurisdiction. That is why state courts must stay fit to receive it.

A state court applying a Commonwealth law, or hearing a case between residents of different States, is exercising federal jurisdiction. Its power then comes from the Commonwealth statute, not state law.

State laws still apply in federal jurisdiction as state law, unless a Commonwealth law makes them inconsistent. But a state law cannot control how a court exercises federal jurisdiction, since state parliaments have no power there.

Section 79 of the Judiciary Act fills that gap. It applies such state laws as Commonwealth law, subject to the Constitution and other Commonwealth laws (Rizeq v Western Australia [2017] HCA 23, joint reasons at [90]-[92], [103]-[105]). In Rizeq, a state jury-verdict rule applied this way, while the state offence applied directly as state law.

This is also why a state court in federal jurisdiction cannot be given a function the Constitution would deny a federal court hearing the same matter.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check if the law is Commonwealth or state. The analysis differs completely depending on which one applies.

For Commonwealth laws, apply Boilermakers both ways. Ask whether Commonwealth judicial power sits in a body that is not a Chapter III court. Also ask whether a federal court has been given functions foreign to judicial power, rather than merely ancillary or incidental to it.

If a function is given to a judge personally, rather than to the court, consider persona designata. This term refers to a judge acting in a personal capacity, separate from their court role. Then test for incompatibility with judicial office.

For state laws, do not apply separation of powers reasoning. Instead apply Kable, and reason from specific indicia. Do not simply assert that a function “looks executive”.

Where a privative clause is involved, apply Kirk. A privative clause is a provision trying to limit court review of a decision. Classify the error involved as jurisdictional or not.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.