Caveats

The effect of lodgement

Once lodged, a caveat stops registration of dealings that conflict with the claimed interest. The registrar will usually refuse to register a transfer or mortgage while the caveat remains.

A caveat does not boost the caveator’s priority against other equitable interests. This is a common misunderstanding. Ordinary rules still decide priority between equitable interests.

The caveat simply preserves the status quo. It does not give the caveator an advantage over others. Its real value is that it puts later dealers on notice.

Lapsing and extension

A caveat can be challenged through a lapsing notice. The registered proprietor, or someone with a registrable dealing, can serve this notice.

The caveator then has a statutory period — often twenty-one days, but this varies — to ask the court to extend the caveat. If they don’t, the caveat lapses automatically and the dealing can go ahead. In New South Wales, this process sits in pt 7A of the Real Property Act 1900.[^cite:real-property-act-1900-nsw-caveats]

On an extension application, the court asks two questions, similar to an interlocutory injunction test. First, is there a serious question to be tried that the caveator holds the interest claimed? Second, does the balance of convenience favour keeping the caveat in place?

The court isn’t deciding the actual dispute here. The caveator usually must give an undertaking as to damages.

A caveat can also be removed by court application, or by the registrar in some jurisdictions. The caveator can withdraw it themselves.

Lodging without reasonable cause

Under the Torrens statutes, a person who lodges or keeps a caveat without reasonable cause must compensate anyone who loses money because of it.

This risk is real. A caveat that delays a property settlement can cause serious loss.

Honestly believing you had reasonable cause is not enough on its own. If that belief was unreasonable, it will not protect you.

So lodging a caveat just to pressure someone, without a genuine proprietary interest, is risky. It is a serious step, not a safe tactic.

Drafting the claim

A caveat must state the estate or interest claimed, the facts behind it, and the land affected. Getting this wrong is the most common mistake.

Claiming too broadly, like a vague “caveatable interest” or “purchaser” without naming the contract, risks rejection or removal.

Claiming too narrowly may miss the caveator’s real interest. This usually cannot be fixed once a lapsing notice is served.

The prohibition should match the interest. Banning all dealings is often wider than needed, and over-claiming risks liability under the compensation provision.

Withdrawal and consent

A caveator can withdraw a caveat whenever they choose. This often happens in exchange for an undertaking, or once the protected transaction is finished.

A caveator can also consent to a specific dealing being registered. The caveat itself stays in force for everything else.

This usually happens when a registered proprietor wants to refinance, and the new mortgage won’t affect the caveator’s interest.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check whether the claimed interest is proprietary. This is called a caveatable interest — a right tied to the land itself. Without one, there is no valid caveat.

Next, work out how the interest arose. It might come from a contract, a trust, a charge, or a statutory right.

If a lapsing notice has been served, apply the set statutory time limit. Explain what happens if the caveator takes no action within it.

If seeking an extension, apply two tests: whether there is a serious question to be tried, and the balance of convenience. Also mention the undertaking as to damages, a promise to cover losses if the caveat turns out wrongful.

Finally, consider whether the caveator could be liable to pay compensation. This matters if the facts suggest the caveat was lodged just to gain leverage.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.