Carers recognition in Tasmania

Three objects, three mechanisms

Section 3 of this Tasmanian Act sets out three objects. These are to recognise, promote and value carers; to enact a Carers Charter and a Tasmanian Carer Action Plan; and to make Agencies monitor and report on both.

The second object matters most structurally. Tasmania creates two separate instruments, not one.

The Charter sits inside the Act, as Schedule 1. The Action Plan is made separately, outside the Act, by the Minister.

This distinction matters because the two instruments are amended differently, and cited differently.

The Charter and the Action Plan

Section 5 sets out the Carers Charter in Schedule 1. This is a Tasmanian law.

The Charter lists seven principles. These cover treating carers as individuals with their own needs, consulting them on policies and programs, giving them access to information and services, supporting their participation in Tasmanian life, recognising and supporting their access to services, respecting their knowledge of the person they care for, and letting them raise concerns without adverse repercussions to the carer or the person cared for.

Each principle says what carers should have or be. Clause 1 is different: it says carers are to be treated as individuals with their own needs. Section 8 confirms this distinction is deliberate.

Section 6(1) requires the Minister to approve a Tasmanian Carer Action Plan. This plan sets out actions for Agencies, or other interested persons or entities, to support carers.

Under s 6(3) the Minister may amend, revoke or substitute the Plan. Under s 6(4) the Minister must send the current version to each Agency’s chief executive officer and publish it on a departmental website.

This Action Plan is unique to Tasmania. Other carers Acts in this series rely on the Charter alone. Tasmania instead uses an executive instrument, changeable without Parliament, and this is where the real commitments to carers sit.

Section 8, and why it matters most

Section 8 is the most important provision in Tasmania’s carers recognition Act. It says the Act does not create a civil cause of action (a basis to sue), does not create legal rights, and does not affect the validity of, or give grounds to review, any judicial or administrative decision. Section 8(3) adds that an Agency does not have to act against another law’s requirements just because of this Act.

This produces three results. First, a carer cannot sue using the Act. Second, a breach of the Act cannot be used as a ground of judicial review (a court checking if a decision was lawful) of an administrative decision, because of s 8(2)(b). For the same reason, the Act cannot be a mandatory relevant consideration — a decision-maker’s failure to consider it only matters if it could ground review, and s 8(2)(b) rules that out.

Third, read s 8(1) narrowly. It only stops the Act being used in a civil cause of action. It is not a blanket rule that the Act is irrelevant for all purposes. Outside civil claims, it is s 8(2)(a) and (b) that do the work of limiting the Act’s effect.

This approach is not unique to Tasmania. Carers recognition statutes generally create duties for organisations, not rights for carers. Tasmania’s Act is different only because it states this expressly, unlike the Western Australian and Northern Territory Acts — which removes room for argument. If a carer’s real complaint is that an agency ignored their caring role, the remedy lies elsewhere: in the statute the agency was actually applying, in anti-discrimination law, or through a complaints process.

Applying this in a problem question

Work through these steps in order, for Tasmania’s carer recognition law.

First, check the relationship. The person cared for must be a family member or friend. If not, the Act does not apply at all.

Next, check the care is unpaid. Then work out which of the six grounds in s 4 applies.

Then check the body involved. It must be a State Service Agency. A contracted provider is not covered by s 7.

Keep the two instruments separate. Work out whether the obligation comes from the Charter in Schedule 1, or from the Action Plan approved under s 6(1).

Apply s 7 exactly as written. It requires reasonable steps to implement, plus monitoring and reporting to the Minister.

Finally, apply s 8 to any remedy sought. Say this explicitly. Finding a Charter breach without addressing s 8 is incomplete.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.