Attempt and withdrawal
The fault element
To prove an attempt, the prosecution must show the conduct element and intention. Intention is the fault element required here, and it is a higher standard than for the completed offence.
A completed offence may sometimes be proved through recklessness, if that is its specified fault element. But an attempt usually needs intention to bring about the result. For Commonwealth offences, Criminal Code s 11.1 sets intention or knowledge as the fault element for attempt. You cannot attempt to be reckless.
This creates a counter-intuitive result. Attempted murder requires intention to kill. Yet completed murder can be proved through reckless indifference, or intention to cause grievous bodily harm.
Impossibility
Impossibility usually does not excuse an attempt. If you try to steal from an empty pocket, or handle goods thinking they are stolen when they are not, you can still be guilty. This is because your fault element was present, and your conduct aimed at the offence you believed you were committing. The Commonwealth Code states this directly.
There is one exception. If the completed act would not be a crime at all, attempting it is not a criminal attempt. Wrongly believing lawful conduct is criminal does not make it an offence.
Withdrawal
Withdrawal from an attempt works differently to withdrawal from complicity. Once the conduct element is met, the attempt is complete. Changing your mind afterwards does not undo the offence, though it may still affect sentencing.
This means withdrawal only helps at an earlier stage. If the accused abandons the plan before their conduct moves from mere preparation into an actual attempt, there is no offence yet to withdraw from.
If the accused is instead a party to someone else’s attempt, the usual complicity withdrawal rules apply. This means they must communicate their withdrawal clearly and in time, and if they gave assistance, take reasonable steps to undo it.
Attempt and the completed offence
You cannot be convicted of both attempt and the completed offence for the same conduct. If the completed offence is proved, the attempt merges into it.
Attempt can be an alternative verdict. This means a jury unsure the full offence happened may convict of attempt instead, without a separate charge. But this option depends on statute, so check it applies to the offence in question.
Attempt usually carries the same penalty as the completed offence, or a set fraction of it. Where the maximum penalty is identical, the lower culpability shows up in sentencing, not in a lower maximum.
The other inchoate offences
Attempt is not the only inchoate offence. Conspiracy and incitement are the other two, and one set of facts can raise all three.
Conspiracy is an agreement between two or more people to commit an offence. It is complete once they agree and intend to carry it out. This catches conduct earlier than attempt, since no further act is needed, though many versions still require an overt act by one party.
Incitement means urging or encouraging someone to commit an offence. It is complete whether or not the offence happens, and whether or not the person agrees.
Each offence has its own elements. Do not call an agreement an “attempt.” Do not call encouragement “complicity” — complicity needs the main offence to actually happen, which is what separates it from incitement.
Offences with their own inchoate forms
Some offences already criminalise preparatory conduct. Examples include possessing a thing with intent, going equipped, and making a document to defraud. Here the prosecution does not need attempt law at all.
Always check for a specific provision first. It may be easier to prove, and it is the charge actually laid.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the substantive offence being attempted. Attempt is parasitic, meaning it only exists by attaching to a defined offence.
Next, apply the conduct test that applies in the relevant jurisdiction. Where the facts are borderline, argue both sides rather than simply asserting a conclusion.
The fault element for attempt is intention. Note if this is a higher standard than the fault element required for the completed offence.
If the facts raise impossibility, address it directly. Distinguish factual impossibility from conduct that would have been lawful if it had been completed.
Only discuss withdrawal in relation to the point when the conduct element was satisfied.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.