Aged care rights and provider obligations

What the Statement of Rights confers

Section 23 sets out rights grouped by subject matter. One group covers independence, autonomy, empowerment and freedom of choice.

Individuals have a right to make decisions affecting their life. This includes choices about their approved funded services, how and by whom these are delivered, and their finances and possessions.

If needed, individuals have a right to support in making these decisions. Their decisions must also be respected. There is also a right to take personal risks, including for quality of life, social participation, and intimate relationships.

Section 23 also confers a right to equitable access to assessment and reassessment. This process must be culturally safe and appropriate, trauma-aware, healing-informed, and suitable for those with dementia or cognitive impairment.

Finally, there is a right to palliative and end-of-life care, when required.

What section 24 does, and what it withholds

Section 24 sets out how the rights actually work. Subsection (1) gives a person the s 23 rights when they access, or try to access, funded aged care services.

Subsection (2) says Parliament intends registered providers to take “all reasonable and proportionate steps” to act compatibly with those rights. But it also recognises rights may need limits. This balances competing rights, the rights of others (including workers and other care recipients), and compliance with other Commonwealth, State or Territory laws, including the Work Health and Safety Act 2011.

Subsection (3) withholds a remedy. Nothing in the Division lets someone enforce these rights or duties through a court or tribunal.

Instead, the Act’s note points elsewhere. Registration conditions can require providers to understand the Statement of Rights and have practices ensuring compatible conduct. A person can also complain to the Complaints Commissioner if a provider acts incompatibly with the rights.

The Statement of Principles

Section 25 sets out a separate Statement of Principles. It says that safety, health, wellbeing and quality of life must be the primary consideration in aged care services.

The principles describe how the system supports providers. This includes putting older people first and recognising rights under the Statement of Rights.

The Statement of Principles and the Statement of Rights are two different instruments. They should not be cited as if they were the same thing.

How the rights reach a provider: conditions of registration

Rights become enforceable against a provider through its registration conditions. Section 144(1) says a registered provider of a kind set out in the rules must show it understands the Statement of Rights. That provider must also have practices ensuring it acts compatibly with those rights, as s 24(2) requires.

Section 144(2) adds a further condition. The provider must show it understands that safety, health, wellbeing and quality of life are the primary consideration.

Two more conditions apply alongside these. Section 145 requires a provider to comply with the Aged Care Code of Conduct, and to take reasonable steps ensuring its workers and responsible persons do too. Section 146 requires a provider of a kind set out in the rules to comply with the Aged Care Quality Standards.

If a provider acts incompatibly with the Statement of Rights, this may raise a question under s 144(1). The question is whether the provider demonstrated understanding and had the required practices, per s 24(2).

However, s 24(3) limits this. It stops the Division itself from creating rights or duties that can be enforced directly in court or tribunal proceedings.

What the Act leaves to the rules

Two key documents providers must follow are not written in the Act itself.

Section 14 lets the rules set requirements for registered providers, their workers and their responsible persons. The Act calls these rules the Aged Care Code of Conduct.

Section 15(1) lets the rules set standards for the quality of funded aged care services. These are called the Aged Care Quality Standards.

Section 15(2) lists, without limiting this power, what the standards may cover. This includes treatment of individuals, governance, physical environments, and safe clinical care.

Because of this structure, students must check the current rules themselves. Citing the Act alone is not enough when answering on the standards.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out which instrument the complaint actually concerns: the Statement of Rights, the Code of Conduct, or the Quality Standards.

If it’s the Statement of Rights, apply s 24(3) before looking at remedies. Don’t treat this as a stand-alone cause of action (a legal basis for suing).

State the s 24(2) standard exactly as the Act does: all reasonable and proportionate steps to act compatibly. This is not an absolute duty to comply.

Work through the three balancing matters in s 24(2)(a)–(c) and say which one applies to your facts.

Then find the condition of registration carrying the obligation: s 144 for the rights, s 145 for the Code of Conduct, s 146 for the Quality Standards.

If the obligation comes from the rules, cite the current rules made under s 14 or s 15(1), and name the compilation you’re relying on.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.