Restrictive practices in aged care

Regulation by condition, and where the detail sits

Section 162 is short. It does not contain the detail itself.

It says who must comply: a registered provider of a kind the rules prescribe. It says they must meet requirements the rules prescribe. But the definitions sit elsewhere.

Section 17(1) defines a restrictive practice. It is any practice or intervention that restricts a person’s rights or freedom of movement.

Section 18(1) lists what the rules must require. This includes last-resort use, proportionality, the least restrictive form, and informed consent.

So you cannot answer a question on this topic from s 162 alone. You need the current rules, plus ss 17 and 18. Section 162 then tells you the consequence: breaching the rules breaches a condition of registration.

There is a second consequence too, under the reportable incident scheme. Section 16(1)(g) makes use of a restrictive practice a reportable incident. But this excludes use that follows the rules’ requirements.

So compliance keeps a restrictive practice outside s 16(1)(g). Non-compliance brings it within that category. Other categories, like unreasonable force or neglect, are separate. The rules may also declare an event is, or is not, reportable (s 16(3)).

The immunity in section 163

Section 163 gives an immunity, but only if strict conditions are met. Three things must be true: the entity is a registered provider covered by s 162; a restrictive practice is used on someone; and that person lacked capacity to give informed consent.

If all this applies, a protected entity gets no civil or criminal liability for using the practice. But this only works before 1 December 2026, and two more things must also be met.

First, informed consent must come from a person or body set out in the rules. Second, the practice must be used according to requirements prescribed under s 162.

The Act says the reverse is also true: no immunity if the rules aren’t followed. So following the rules isn’t just a separate duty — it’s what the immunity depends on.

Section 163(3) says a protected entity includes both the registered provider and any individual who used or helped use the restrictive practice. So the immunity can cover workers, not just the organisation.

The date matters

Section 163 only protects conduct before 1 December 2026. Both the consent and the actual use of the restrictive practice must happen before that date.

This is a limit on the protection, not just a start date. Answers using s 163 must deal with this limit directly.

If the consent or the use happens after that date, s 163 does not apply. Liability then depends on general law and whatever consent rules apply at the time.

For someone who lacks capacity, this may include the substitute decision-making law of their State or Territory.

How this differs from the NDIS approach

The NDIS and aged care schemes treat restrictive practices differently.

Under the NDIS rules, a provider’s registration conditions link directly to State and Territory processes. A use must be authorised under the jurisdiction’s own process. Evidence of this must be lodged with the Commissioner.

The aged care provision works differently. It does not mention State authorisation at all. Instead, it points only to the Commonwealth rules, and to consent from a person or body those rules name.

Do not assume aged care works like the NDIS. Whether State law applies to an aged care use depends on the Commonwealth rules and relevant State law. You cannot answer this by comparing it to the NDIS scheme.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check that s 162 applies to this provider under the rules. Do this before anything else.

Next, find the specific requirements in the rules, not just the Act. Cite the rules with their compilation details.

Then ask if the use complied with those requirements. This single question decides two things: whether there’s a registration breach, and whether it’s a reportable incident under s 16(1)(g). Note that s 16(1)(g) also covers alleged or suspected non-compliant use, not just proven breaches. Also check any rules made under s 16(3).

For immunity under s 163(1), all three preconditions must be met. One of these is that the individual lacked capacity to give informed consent (meaning they couldn’t understand and agree to the decision themselves).

Separately, s 163(2) has two limbs, and both must be satisfied. Both the consent and the compliant use must have occurred before 1 December 2026.

Finally, don’t apply the NDIS State-authorisation model here. Aged care has its own distinct framework.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.