Aged and disability care law in South Australia

Commonwealth or State?

The Commonwealth funds and regulates aged care and disability services. Aged care is funded and regulated under the Aged Care Act 2024 (Cth). Disability supports are funded and regulated under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

Things like provider registration, quality standards, worker screening, and reportable incidents are Commonwealth matters. Income support is also Commonwealth.

South Australia governs the person themselves. This includes who can decide for an adult who cannot decide for themselves, what refusing treatment means, who can authorise a restrictive practice, what happens if an adult is abused, and who hears service complaints. These are State questions, answered by South Australian law.

The two systems overlap most in restrictive practices. There, a Commonwealth rule requires a State authorisation. This overlap is covered later, and it’s where students most often get the jurisdiction wrong.

The seven statutes, and what each answers

South Australia’s aged and disability care law sits across seven Acts. Each one answers a different practical question.

The Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 (SA) asks whether an adult can decide for themselves, and who decides if not. SACAT (the tribunal) makes that call.

The Advance Care Directives Act 2013 (SA) covers what someone decided in advance about their health care. A substitute decision-maker acts on it, and SACAT resolves disputes.[^cite:sa-guardianship-administration-1993]

The Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA) deals with who can manage a person’s property and money. The donee (the person given this power) does so, supervised by the court.[^cite:sa-advance-care-directives-2013]

The Disability Inclusion Act 2018 (SA), Part 5A, asks whether a restrictive practice may be used. An Authorised Program Officer or Senior Authorising Officer decides this.[^cite:sa-powers-of-attorney-1984]

The Ageing and Adult Safeguarding Act 1995 (SA) applies where an adult is being abused. The Adult Safeguarding Unit responds, with SACAT involved where needed.[^cite:sa-disability-inclusion-2018]

The Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2004 (SA) governs complaints about services. The Commissioner hears these complaints.[^cite:sa-ageing-adult-safeguarding-1995]

The Carers Recognition Act 2005 (SA) asks whether an unpaid carer has recognised standing. Applicable organisations determine this.[^cite:sa-health-complaints-2004]

Capacity and substitute decision-making

South Australia’s Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 (SA) defines mental incapacity in s 3. It means a person cannot look after their own health, safety, welfare or affairs.

Section 5 sets principles for every decision made under the Act. Section 5(d) requires the least restrictive option that still protects the person properly.

SACAT can make guardianship orders (s 29) or administration orders (s 35). These orders may be limited, not full, so any claim that a full order is needed should be checked against s 5(d) and the limited-order power.

The Advance Care Directives Act 2013 (SA) deals with decisions made before incapacity. Two points are easy to get wrong.

Section 7(2)(d) says an unwise decision does not, by itself, show impaired capacity. Making a risky choice is not the same as being incapable.

Section 19(1) only makes a refusal of health care binding. Positive requests in a directive are not binding in the same way, even though students often assume they are.

Section 13 keeps the two kinds of document separate. An advance care directive cannot create a power of attorney; any clause trying to do so is void under s 13(2).

So financial and property authority must come from elsewhere, and there are two possible routes. If the person made an enduring power of attorney while capable, the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA) applies.

If they did not, SACAT can make an administration order under s 35 of the 1993 Act. The administrator then controls the estate and, under s 39(2)(a), may sell the protected person’s property.

In practice the second route matters most, because an enduring power can no longer be made once capacity is lost — usually the point at which the issue arises.

The 1984 Act is older and more detailed. Section 6 sets the formal requirements for making an enduring power of attorney.

Section 7 requires the donee (the person given the power) to act with reasonable diligence to protect the donor’s interests. Sections 8 and 9 cover accounts and what happens if the donee fails in these duties.

Section 14 limits when an interstate enduring power of attorney will be recognised in South Australia.

Abuse of an older or vulnerable adult

South Australia has its own law on this: the Ageing and Adult Safeguarding Act 1995 (SA).

It covers a “relevant adult” (s 3(1)): someone 18 or over who may be vulnerable to abuse. Abuse (s 4(1)) means conduct within a relationship of trust, dependency, or imbalance of power.

Two key features. First, reporting abuse is voluntary, not compulsory. Section 22(4)(a) says nothing requires a person to report suspected abuse.

Second, the response is consent-based. The Adult Safeguarding Unit generally needs the adult’s consent to act, with exceptions under s 28. SACAT can still authorise action the adult has refused, under s 33(1)(c).

So in South Australia, an adult’s refusal is normally respected, unless a tribunal overrides it. The passage notes New South Wales and Queensland use different models, so this approach may not apply there.

Complaints, and carers

This South Australian Act, the Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2004 (SA), creates a Commissioner. Section 24 says who may complain, and it is not just the consumer.

A substitute decision-maker may complain. So may another person, if it would be unreasonable to expect the consumer to complain themselves (s 24(da) and (g)). Use this provision when a client is too unwell or dependent to complain personally.

The Carers Recognition Act 2005 (SA) defines a care relationship in s 5(1), based on five reasons. Paid, volunteer and training relationships are excluded (s 5(2)).

Section 6(1) requires an applicable organisation to take practicable steps so its staff understand the Carers Charter. This duty falls on organisations only. It does not give carers an enforceable right, so do not tell a carer the Charter lets them personally enforce anything.

Self-check

Before answering, check your work on this South Australian aged and disability care problem.

Say which government’s law applies to each part of the question. Some issues are Commonwealth, others are South Australian.

Check whether a directive or power of attorney already exists. Only propose a SACAT application if there is no existing one covering the issue.

Apply the least-restrictive principle in s 5(d) when proposing any order. The order should restrict the person no more than necessary.

Remember an advance care directive only binds as to refusals. It does not bind as to other instructions.

Name both the Commonwealth rule and the South Australian Part when discussing a restrictive practice. Both levels of law may apply.

Remember South Australian adult safeguarding is consent-based. Reporting is voluntary, not compulsory.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.