Advance personal planning in the Northern Territory
The decision-making cascade
Section 22 (Northern Territory) sets a strict order for decision makers to follow.
First, the decision maker must follow any advance care statement the person made, under s 22(2). This applies subject to exemptions in s 23(1) and (2).
Second, if there is no advance care statement on the matter, s 22(3) requires the decision maker to act as they reasonably believe the person would act. This is called substituted judgment: deciding what the person would do, not what they would want.
Section 22(4) says the decision maker must consider the person’s current and past views, wishes and objections. They must also consider their own personal knowledge of the person. This personal knowledge is a required factor, reflecting why decision makers are chosen.
Third, if the decision maker cannot reasonably form a belief about what the person would do, s 22(7) applies. They must then act in what they reasonably believe is the person’s best interests, considering all relevant factors under s 22(8).
Substituted judgment prevails over best interests
This section is about the Northern Territory. Section 22(5) follows the person’s own likely wishes, called substituted judgment. The decision maker must act this way even if they think it is not in the person’s best interests.
Section 22(6) limits this rule. It says the decision maker does not have to give the person addictive substances with no therapeutic benefit, even if the person would use them.
This exception shows how strong the general rule in s 22(5) is. The drafter needed a specific carve-out to stop substituted judgment applying in that one situation.
Two standards in one Territory
The Northern Territory uses two different tests, depending on who appointed the decision maker.
If the adult made an advance personal plan, the appointed decision maker follows a set order. They apply advance care statements first, then substituted judgment (deciding what the adult would have wanted), and only then best interests. Section 22(5) makes best interests give way to substituted judgment.
If the Tribunal appointed a guardian instead, under the Guardianship of Adults Act 2016 (NT), that guardian must act in the adult’s best interests (s 4(2)). This follows a structured process, not the same order as above.
So before stating the legal standard, you must first identify how the decision maker got their authority. The same adult, in the same Territory, can face different legal tests depending on whether they planned ahead. This is a good reason to make a plan, and a trap for students who assume one standard applies across the whole jurisdiction.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which part of the plan applies: an advance consent decision, an advance care statement, or an appointed decision maker.
If an advance care statement covers the issue, apply s 22(2) and follow it, but only subject to s 23(1) and (2).
If no statement covers it, use s 22(3). Ask what the person would have decided, not what seems best for them, subject to s 23(2).
Under s 22(4), consider the person’s past statements and the decision maker’s personal knowledge, not just current wishes.
If substituted judgment and the person’s interests conflict, apply s 22(5) directly, and also check s 22(6).
Only fall back on best interests under s 22(7) if no reasonable belief about the person’s wishes can be formed. Confirm the authority comes from this Act, not the guardianship Act.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.