Advance directives compared: what binds, and what merely guides
Question 1: scope
Quick Read: scope varies a lot by jurisdiction.
The ACT has the narrowest instrument. Section 7 of its Act lets a health direction only refuse treatment or require its withdrawal. It cannot be used to demand treatment be given.
The Northern Territory has the broadest instrument. Section 8(1) lets one document do three things: make advance consent decisions, record care statements, and appoint decision makers.
South Australia keeps things separate. Section 13 says an advance care directive cannot give a power of attorney. For financial and legal affairs, a separate power of attorney is needed under different legislation. An answer that blends the two has got the scope wrong.
Western Australia and Tasmania place their instruments inside guardianship legislation, not a standalone Act. Looking for a separate Act in these two states is a common mistake.
Queensland puts its advance health directive in its Powers of Attorney Act. This is the one jurisdiction where the two instruments sit in the same Act.
Which standard governs the substitute
Two different standards decide what a substitute decision-maker should do, and different places use different ones.
Substituted judgment asks what the person themselves would have decided. Victoria uses this under s 61(1), with personal and social wellbeing as a fallback under s 61(3) if their wishes cannot be worked out. The Northern Territory uses a strong version under s 22, falling back to best interests under s 22(7).
Other instruments use welfare, interests, or a structured best interests standard instead. In New South Wales, s 4 of the Guardianship Act 1987 makes welfare and interests paramount. In the Northern Territory, s 4 of the Guardianship of Adults Act 2016 applies a structured best interests standard to guardianship decisions, but not to health care decisions, which it excludes.
That Northern Territory best interests standard is also qualified by s 4(7). This requires an adult’s advance care statement to be followed even if it is not in their best interests, unless an exception applies.
The Northern Territory therefore has both standards operating, but under different instruments. Before applying either standard, first work out which instrument actually governs the situation.
Comparison
South Australia’s Advance Care Directives Act 2013 covers health care, residential and accommodation matters, and personal affairs (s 11(3)). It cannot be used to give someone a power of attorney (s 13). Only refusals of treatment actually bind (s 19(1)).
Victoria’s Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016 applies to health care. Instructional directives bind the decision-maker, but values directives only guide them (s 12).
Queensland’s advance health directive sits inside the Powers of Attorney Act 1998. It binds, but only if the preconditions in s 36 are met, and it outranks an attorney’s decision (s 35).
The Northern Territory uses two Acts together, the Advance Personal Planning Act 2013 and Health Care Decision Making Act 2023. These combine consent decisions, care statements and appointments in one scheme. The decision-maker must apply substituted judgment, meaning they follow what the person would have wanted, even if this goes against the person’s current interests (s 22).
The ACT’s Medical Treatment (Health Directions) Act 2006 only covers refusing or withdrawing treatment (s 7). Whether the direction binds depends on its form and how it was witnessed (ss 7(2), 8, 9).
In WA and Tasmania, advance directives sit inside each state’s guardianship legislation. WA’s rules come from the Guardianship and Administration Act 1990, Part 9B, with binding effect set out in ss 110S and 110U. Tasmania’s Guardianship and Administration Act 1995, Part 5A, works the same way, with binding effect governed by that Part.
NSW deals with this through the Guardianship Act 1987, Part 5, which covers consent to medical and dental treatment. Binding effect depends on ss 33A, 37, 40 and 46A.
A working method
First, find the instrument in the correct Act. In WA and Tasmania it sits inside guardianship law. In Queensland it sits inside the powers of attorney law.
Next, classify what you have. Victoria uses instructional directives or values directives. South Australia uses refusals or requests. The ACT uses refusals or withdrawals.
Then check formalities against the required form. This matters most in the ACT.
Work out which has authority: the directive itself, or an appointed substitute decision-maker.
Match the legal standard to the type of instrument, not to habit or assumption.
In Queensland, life-sustaining measures need every precondition in s 36 satisfied. These preconditions are cumulative, so all must be met together.
Self-check
Before relying on an advance directive, check a few things.
First, find where the directive actually sits. Some jurisdictions place it inside the guardianship Act or the powers of attorney Act, not a separate statute.
Then work out what binds and what only guides. The statute’s own wording tells you this, so check its terms directly.
Next, check whether the directive can substitute for a power of attorney. Some jurisdictions allow this; others forbid it.
Finally, only apply substituted judgment (making the decision the person would have made) where that jurisdiction’s law actually requires it.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.