Advance care directives in Tasmania
What the Part sets out to do
Section 35A sets out the objects of this Part. These include letting people with decision-making ability give directions about future health care, and state their preferences and values, including outcomes or interventions they want to avoid.
The objects also aim to make health care follow the person’s directions as far as reasonably practicable. They aim to protect health practitioners who follow these directives, and to provide ways to resolve disputes about them.
Paragraph (b) is significant. Like South Australia’s s 9(b), it lets a directive cover more than refusals of treatment. A person can specify an outcome to avoid, not just a treatment to refuse. This is broader than the ACT’s health direction, which only allows refusals.
Paragraph (d) is practically important too. Protecting practitioners who act on a directive is itself a stated object. This supports interpreting doubtful cases in favour of giving effect to the directive.
The presumption, stated for health care
Section 35B(c) sets out a presumption just for health care decisions. It says an adult is presumed to have decision-making ability about their health care, unless evidence or a Tasmanian law says otherwise.
This is different from Queensland’s approach. Queensland states a general presumption of capacity for any matter. Tasmania instead places its presumption specifically within the health directive Part.
Section 35B(d) adds another rule. A person must be allowed to make their own health care decisions, but only to the extent they are able. This means capacity can be partial, not just present or absent entirely.
Quality of life is the person’s to define
Section 35B(b) is a Tasmanian provision. It says a person with decision-making ability can decide what counts as quality of life for them. They can write this in an advance care directive.
This matters when a clinician or family member disagrees with the person’s choice. The Act puts that judgement in the person’s hands, not the assessor’s.
A student discussing how much weight a directive carries should point to this specific provision. Arguing about quality of life in the abstract misses the point.
Autonomy may be exercised collaboratively
Section 35B(e) is the stand-out provision in this Part. It says a person can exercise autonomy by deciding alone, deciding collaboratively with family or community, or a mix of both. This depends on the person’s culture, background, history or spiritual or religious beliefs.
This provision is similar to South Australia’s s 10(e). It treats a decision made with family or community as the person exercising their own autonomy. It does not treat this as proof of undue influence (improper pressure) or proof the person failed to decide for themselves.
This matters in practice. It means you cannot argue a directive deserves less weight just because it was made collectively. This goes against s 35B(e).
The Northern Territory deals with similar ideas differently. It recognises customary law when deciding who counts as the health care decision maker. Tasmania’s approach is different: it focuses on how a person decides, not who the decider is.
Applying this in a problem question
In a Tasmanian problem question, apply the s 8 principles alongside s 35B, not instead of it. Identify which s 8 principle supports your argument.
Start from s 35B(c). This presumes a person can make their own health care decisions.
If the person only partly retains that ability, apply s 35B(d) instead. Capacity is not all-or-nothing.
Where quality of life is disputed, apply s 35B(b). This leaves that judgement to the person themselves.
If the directive was made with family or community involved, apply s 35B(e). Treat this as support, not a weakness.
Finally, explain the directive’s effect through s 35B(f). This is the person’s own authority, not just evidence of past wishes.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.