Advance care directives in South Australia
When capacity is impaired
This is about South Australia’s advance care directives law. Under s 7(1)(a), a person has impaired decision-making capacity for a particular decision if they cannot understand relevant information, cannot retain it, cannot use it to decide, or cannot communicate their decision. Capacity is judged for each specific decision, not generally.
Section 7(1)(b) adds that a person also has impaired capacity if they meet any test for this set out in their own directive.
Section 7(2) sets safeguards. Understanding technical or trivial details isn’t required. Retaining information only briefly still counts as capacity. Capacity can fluctuate between impaired and full.
Importantly, a decision isn’t impaired merely because it may lead to an adverse outcome for the person. This anti-paternalism safeguard is often the key point argued in practice.
What a directive cannot do
Section 12(1) lists what a directive cannot include, under South Australian law. It cannot be unlawful or require an unlawful act. It cannot cause a health practitioner to breach a professional standard or code of conduct that applies to them. It cannot refuse mandatory medical treatment (treatment required by law). It also cannot cover anything the regulations declare falls within this section.
Section 12(2) narrows the professional standards rule. It excludes standards or codes made by a hospital, clinic, hospice, nursing home or similar place, just to regulate services there. So a facility’s own policy cannot invalidate a directive.
Section 12(3) sets out the consequence of breaking these rules. The offending provision is void, but only to the extent of the contravention. The rest of the directive survives; only the bad part is severed.
Two further limits apply. Section 12(1a) says a directive cannot be a request for voluntary assisted dying, though a person may still express preferences or wishes about it. Section 13 says a directive cannot grant a power of attorney (authority to act for someone); financial authority must come from a separate document.
Binding and non-binding provisions
This part of the Act applies in South Australia. Section 19(1) says a provision refusing particular health care, whether express or implied, is a binding provision. Section 19(3) says every other kind of provision is non-binding.
This split matters a lot. A refusal binds. But an instruction to give treatment, a statement of values, or a wish about care or living arrangements is never binding, no matter how clearly it’s written.
Non-binding provisions still matter, though. Under s 35(1)(a), a substitute decision-maker must, as far as reasonably practicable, follow the directive’s instructions and consider the person’s wishes. But s 6(1) says nothing in the Act lets a directive force a health practitioner to give particular treatment.
There are two further limits on binding provisions. Section 19(2) says a binding provision that only applies in specified circumstances binds only in those circumstances. Section 19(1a) also makes one type of refusal non-binding regardless: refusing care connected to the person’s own attempted suicide or self-harm.
Finally, s 20 says a directive otherwise takes effect according to its terms, subject to the Act and other law.
The substitute decision-maker’s preconditions
In South Australia, a substitute decision-maker named in a directive cannot just act freely. Section 24(1) sets three conditions that must all be met before they can make a decision.
First, they must produce the directive when a health practitioner asks for it. Second, no law or Act must prevent them from acting under it. Third, they must be competent at the time they make the decision.
Section 24(2) explains how the “production” condition can be satisfied. This can be done with a certified true copy, through an approved electronic scheme, or by the practitioner accessing an electronic copy as the regulations allow.
Applying this in a problem question
In South Australia, start by pinpointing the exact decision in question. Apply s 7(1)(a) to that one decision, not to the person’s capacity in general.
Then work through the s 7(2) safeguards. If someone argues incapacity just because the decision seems unwise, use s 7(2)(d) specifically for that argument.
Next, classify the provision. If it refuses health care, it is binding under s 19(1). If it is something else, it is non-binding under s 19(3) — meaning it guides but doesn’t compel.
If the refusal concerns attempted suicide or self-harm, also check s 19(1a).
Test the provision against s 12. If it breaches s 12, sever just that part under s 12(3), rather than voiding the whole directive.
Finally, for any substitute decision-maker’s choice, check all three preconditions in s 24(1). This includes confirming the substitute decision-maker is themselves competent.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.