Procedural fairness

The hearing rule

The case Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH (2015) removed “legitimate expectation” as a way to decide if procedural fairness applies, or what it requires. The judges said this concept can distract from the real question: what fairness demands in the circumstances. So arguments should focus on practical unfairness, not on expectations being disappointed.

The hearing rule says a person affected by a decision must get a genuine chance to put their case first. Kioa v West is the leading case: a deportation decision was overturned because the person was never given a chance to respond to adverse material used against them.

In practice, this usually means three things. The person needs fair notice of the case against them, detailed enough to let them respond properly. They also need a genuine opportunity to respond — a real chance to give evidence and make submissions, not just a token gesture after the decision is already made. The decision should only be made once this opportunity has genuinely been given.

What the hearing rule requires depends heavily on context. It does not always mean an oral hearing, cross-examination, or a lawyer must be involved. The content of the rule shifts depending on the decision’s nature, what is at stake for the person, and the statutory scheme involved.

When the duty arises

You don’t need a court-like process for procedural fairness to apply. The duty arises whenever a decision will affect someone’s rights or interests.

This trigger is broad. It covers more than strict legal rights. It includes practical interests, like keeping a benefit, licence or status you already have.

A clear statute can exclude or change this duty. But courts rarely assume this unless the law is very clear. Procedural fairness is treated as a basic assumption about how decision-making powers should work.

Content is not fixed

Procedural fairness is not a fixed checklist. What it requires changes with context.

Context includes the type of decision, how it affects the person, and the relevant statutory scheme.

Some decisions need stronger procedures. Cancelling a long-held licence usually demands more than a routine, low-stakes decision does.

Avoid treating “the rules of procedural fairness” as uniform. Instead, ask what fairness required in that specific situation.

Procedural fairness and jurisdictional error

Denying procedural fairness is a serious legal problem, not a small mistake. Courts usually read decision-making powers as only valid if used fairly.

So a decision made without procedural fairness can involve jurisdictional error. This means the decision may be treated as if it was never validly made at all, not just flawed.

This shows a strong link between procedural fairness and judicial review generally. Fair process is not just good practice. It can be a legal requirement for a decision to be valid in the first place.

No single national standard

Procedural fairness is a shared idea across Australian law. But the exact requirements depend on whether the decision is made under Commonwealth, state or territory law. Some statutes even set their own procedures, which can change the general common law rules. So the broad concept carries over, but the detailed requirements do not automatically transfer between different statutory schemes.

In 2026, the High Court confirmed the limits on this duty in GXT25 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship. The Court applied the Alphaone principle, as approved in SZBEL. A decision-maker must tell a person about any critical issue that isn’t obvious from the statute or the case’s nature. They must also flag any adverse conclusion that wasn’t clearly open on the material known to the person.

Only with these two qualifications in place is the decision-maker otherwise free from exposing their reasoning or tentative views before deciding.

The Court also held that there’s no duty to invite comment on adverse information from another source, if the inferences drawn from it were already obviously open on what the person already knew. So it doesn’t matter where the material came from. What matters is whether the conclusion was already obvious from the known material.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the decision. Ask if it affects the person’s rights or interests. This triggers a duty of procedural fairness.

Do not use “legitimate expectation”. The case WZARH says this concept is unnecessary and unhelpful. It will not earn marks.

Next, check the statute. See if it expressly, or by clear implication, changes or excludes the usual common law duty.

Then apply the hearing rule. Ask whether the person got fair notice of the case against them. Also check if they had a genuine chance to respond before the decision.

Apply the bias rule too. Ask whether a fair-minded, informed observer might reasonably suspect the decision-maker was not impartial.

Finally, if there is a breach, explain why it may be a jurisdictional error. This means the decision-maker exceeded their legal power. Then state what remedy would follow.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.