Merits review
Standing in the shoes of the decision-maker
Merits review means the reviewer steps into the decision-maker’s role. It can look at the facts again, weigh evidence, and apply the law itself. It then decides the “correct or preferable decision” — a standard set in Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577.
Even if the original decision was lawful and made in good faith, the reviewer can still change it if it disagrees.
This differs from judicial review. Judicial review only asks whether the decision-maker stayed within their legal powers. Merits review asks a broader question: what decision should actually have been made.
Internal review
Internal review happens within the same agency. A more senior officer reconsiders the original decision.
This can happen before or instead of external review, depending on the scheme.
It is often quicker and less formal than a tribunal. But it is not independent, since the reviewer belongs to the same agency being challenged.
Tribunal merits review
Some statutes let you ask a tribunal to review a decision, not just the original decision-maker. Tribunals exercise administrative power, not judicial power. But they often look court-like, with hearings, evidence-gathering powers and published reasons.
The Commonwealth has a general tribunal that reviews many federal administrative decisions. States and territories generally have their own equivalent tribunals for decisions under their own laws.
Tribunal names and structures have changed over time, and coverage varies between schemes. So a student should check the specific legislation for the decision in question, not assume one uniform model.
Not every decision carries a right to merits review. That right only exists if the particular statute creating the decision confers it.
Limits of merits review
Merits review has limits. A reviewer can only review decisions and entities that its enabling legislation covers. It has no general power to review any executive action it dislikes.
Merits review usually applies the law and policy current at the time of its own decision. This can mean the result differs from what was correct when the original decision was made.
The reviewer’s decision is itself administrative. So it can face further review, either by a higher tribunal (if one exists) or by judicial review on legality grounds.
Why the distinction from judicial review matters
Merits review lets a reviewer swap in a different outcome, just because it prefers it. This can fix a decision that was lawful but, in the reviewer’s view, wrong on the facts or on how a discretion was used. Judicial review cannot do this.
If there is no right to merits review — because the statute gives none, or that type of decision is excluded — judicial review is the only option left. But judicial review only checks legality, not whether the decision was correct.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by finding the statute behind the decision. Check whether it gives a right to internal review, tribunal review, or both.
If a review right exists, work out the correct forum. Note any time limits or procedural steps that must be met first.
Remember the standard applied is the correct or preferable decision. This is not the same as simply checking legality.
Think about what new evidence or arguments might change the result. Merits review involves a fresh, complete look at the case.
If no merits review right exists, say so clearly. Explain that the person may need to consider judicial review instead.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.