Judicial review of administrative action

Legality, not merits

Judicial review focuses on legality, not merits. Courts check whether a decision-maker had the power to act, not whether their choice was the best one.

If a decision-maker had a discretion and used it lawfully, a court cannot overturn it. This is true even if the judge would have made a different decision.

This limit comes from the separation of powers. Courts supervise the boundaries of executive power, but they do not take over the executive’s job of choosing the best outcome.

Telling legality and merits apart is often hard in practice. Much of the skill in judicial review is showing that a complaint is really about legal limits, not a hidden complaint about the result.

No single national scheme

Australia has no single law covering judicial review. The Commonwealth has its own statute, the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth), which lists the grounds of review[^cite:adjr-act-1977-s5-grounds].

This Act only governs Commonwealth decision-makers. States and Territories are different: each has its own law, and you cannot assume it mirrors the Commonwealth Act.

The cause of action, remedies, and procedural steps all depend on which regime applies. Always check which jurisdiction’s law governs the decision you are reviewing.

Section 75(v) and constitutional entrenchment

Section 75(v) of the Constitution gives the High Court power to hear matters directly against Commonwealth officers. It can order mandamus, prohibition, or an injunction against them. These are remedies compelling or stopping official action.

Because the Constitution itself grants this power, Parliament cannot remove it by ordinary law. This includes a privative clause, which is a law trying to shield a decision from judicial review. So there is always a constitutional minimum of review available, no matter what the statute says.

This minimum is closely linked to jurisdictional error, covered elsewhere. A privative clause cannot validly exclude review for jurisdictional error.

However, having this constitutional jurisdiction does not mean it works as an alternative shortcut. In San Bao Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the Court said it is not a concurrent review path for someone who missed the strict statutory time limits.

Generally, review should go through the normal hierarchy of tribunals and courts first. Skipping that hierarchy will often be an abuse of process, unless the case is exceptional due to importance, merits, or urgency. Simply having no other avenue left is not enough, by itself, to count as exceptional.

In Plaintiff S32/2026 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the Court applied this reasoning. It found an application for constitutional writs against a protection visa refusal was an abuse of process, on its specific facts.

The plaintiff had not taken part in the Tribunal’s merits review, and the Tribunal had rejected his explanations for that. He had not challenged either Tribunal decision for jurisdictional error. He could still seek judicial review of the Tribunal’s later decision elsewhere, and succeeding there would send him back to merits review.

The Court also noted that, regardless, the visa decision was not affected by jurisdictional error anyway. Both cases concerned review under the same migration legislation.

Remedies

Courts use old names for judicial review remedies. Certiorari quashes (cancels) an invalid decision. Mandamus orders a decision-maker to perform a duty. Prohibition stops an unlawful use of power.

Courts can also grant declarations (formal statements of legal rights) or injunctions (orders stopping action).

Every remedy is discretionary. This means a court can refuse it even if a ground of review is proven, for example due to delay or if granting it would serve no real purpose.

Applying this in a problem question

First, identify the decision-maker and the source of their power. Check whether they are a Commonwealth, state or territory officer. This matters because it affects which judicial review regime applies.

Next, work out whether the complaint is about illegality, procedural unfairness, or unreasonableness (or more than one). Test whether the complaint is really about legality, not about the merits of the decision.

On unreasonableness, do not assume the ground only covers decisions that are irrational or bizarre. In Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li, Hayne, Kiefel and Bell JJ said unreasonableness is a conclusion applied to a decision lacking an “evident and intelligible justification” — meaning the decision cannot be sensibly explained.

In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW, Kiefel CJ applied that same test and described it as necessarily stringent, meaning hard to satisfy. Nettle and Gordon JJ reasoned that it would be rare to find a discretion unreasonable if the decision-maker’s reasons showed a justification.

If the decision-maker is a Commonwealth officer, consider whether s 75(v) is engaged. Also consider whether a privative clause (a provision trying to limit review) could validly exclude the ground relied on.

Check too whether a statutory review route is, or was, available. If so, going straight to the High Court instead might be treated as an abuse of process.

Identify the remedy sought, and consider discretionary reasons a court might refuse to grant it.

Throughout, keep merits review and judicial review analytically separate, even where both might be factually available.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.