What is administrative action?

Distinguishing legislative action

Legislative action means making general rules. These rules bind many people or situations, not just one person’s case. Parliament makes statutes. The executive can also make delegated legislation, like regulations, under statutory power. These too set general norms, rather than deciding one person’s situation.

The line between legislative and administrative action is not always clear. One instrument might look legislative but act like an individual decision, or the reverse. Courts ask whether the instrument creates a general rule for the future, or applies an existing rule to one case.

Applying existing criteria to one person’s file suggests an administrative decision. Changing the criteria for everyone suggests a legislative one. This is true even if the same official uses the same statutory power.

No single feature decides the classification alone. Courts weigh all relevant features of the statutory scheme together (RG Capital Radio Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority (2001) 113 FCR 185 at [42], [78]).

This distinction matters for two reasons. First, legislative instruments usually face their own accountability checks, such as parliamentary scrutiny, disallowance, and publication rules. Individual administrative decisions do not usually face these same checks.

Second, administrative law’s grounds of review focus on decisions about particular facts. They are not designed to question the wisdom of general rules.

Distinguishing judicial action

Judicial action is a court’s final, binding decision on a legal dispute. It applies law to facts and conclusively settles the parties’ rights. Section 71 of the Constitution gives this power to the High Court, federal courts, and courts given federal jurisdiction.

Administrative decisions can look similar. They also apply law to facts and produce an outcome affecting someone.

But administrative action is different. It lacks the court’s independence and its binding, conclusive effect. It also stays open to merits review, judicial review, or both.

For example, a tribunal doing merits review exercises administrative power, not judicial power. This is true even though its process looks like a court’s.

Why the distinction matters

This classification isn’t just academic. It shapes three things.

First, what accountability applies. Administrative action can usually be reviewed on its merits, by internal review or a tribunal, and challenged for legal error through judicial review. Legislative instruments are mainly checked by parliament instead. Judicial decisions are only corrected by appeal, or rarely, other judicial means.

Second, what standard courts use. Judicial review asks whether administrative action was legal, not whether it was the best choice — courts won’t substitute their own preferred outcome. This reflects separation of powers: courts check legality without performing the executive’s role themselves.

Third, who can sue, and what remedies exist. Remedies like quashing a decision, or ordering a decision-maker to act lawfully, are built specifically around the nature of administrative power.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding who made the decision and where their power comes from. It might come from a statute, delegated legislation, the prerogative, or a contract or policy.

Next, work out if the decision applies an existing rule to specific facts. That is administrative action. If it creates a new rule for everyone, that is legislative action instead.

Then check who made the decision. Courts using judicial power act differently to executive officers or tribunals. The latter two are administrative.

Some decisions will not fit neatly into these categories. Where this happens, explain which label fits best, and why.

Finally, once you have labelled the decision as administrative action, work out which accountability mechanism applies. This could be internal review, tribunal merits review, or judicial review. Only then apply that mechanism’s specific rules.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.