Health Care Complaints Commission (NSW)

A short factsheet on the HCCC: the NSW body that investigates health-service complaints and can itself prosecute registered practitioners before NCAT.

Learning level
Orientation
Jurisdictions
nsw
Subjects
administrative-law, ethics-and-professional-responsibility
Topics
statutory-bodies-and-regulators

Learning outcomes

  • State the HCCC’s establishing Act and its complaint-handling function for NSW health services.
  • Explain that, unlike most bodies in this overlay set, the HCCC can itself prosecute a complaint against a registered practitioner before NCAT.
  • Distinguish the HCCC’s sector-specific complaints role from the NSW Ombudsman’s general administration complaints role.

Act: Health Care Complaints Act 1993 (NSW).1

Established: under the 1993 Act, subsuming the former Health Complaints Unit and adding conciliation and prosecution powers.

Purpose: The HCCC receives, assesses and investigates complaints about the professional conduct, clinical care and administrative practices of registered and unregistered health service providers in NSW. The protection of public health and safety is the paramount consideration in how it exercises its functions.

Powers conferred under the Act

The Commission investigates complaints and assesses whether a matter is serious enough to warrant prosecution. Depending on the profession and the seriousness of the conduct, a matter can be prosecuted before the Occupational Division of NCAT or a Professional Standards Committee, or dealt with by referral to the relevant NSW Health Professional Council.

Is it a prosecuting authority?

Yes, in a specific and limited sense. The answer is genuinely “yes,” and it is worth getting exactly right: the HCCC’s Director of Proceedings can prosecute a complaint against a registered health practitioner before NCAT’s Occupational Division. The HCCC’s prosecuting power is still narrow — it is limited to disciplinary proceedings against registered practitioners, not a general criminal prosecution power over the public.

How it relates to the other NSW bodies

Complaints about a hospital’s clinical service or a practitioner’s conduct sit with the HCCC; complaints about how an unrelated NSW agency handled an administrative matter sit with the NSW Ombudsman instead. When the HCCC prosecutes before NCAT, the matter is heard by NCAT’s Occupational Division, not by the HCCC itself sitting as a decision-maker. Depending on the disciplinary pathway, the HCCC may instead prosecute before another appropriate body, such as a Professional Standards Committee.

Self-check

  • Have I stated correctly that the HCCC can prosecute registered practitioners before NCAT, rather than assuming every health complaints body is conciliation-only?
  • Have I distinguished this narrow disciplinary prosecuting power from a general criminal prosecution power?
  • Have I kept the HCCC’s disciplinary prosecution role distinct from the complaint-resolution role of bodies that do not prosecute practitioners before a disciplinary tribunal?

Pop quiz

3 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.